SETI: Dr Andrea Melis and the Challenge of a Mysterious Signal
The search for extraterrestrial intelligence is one of the most fascinating and complex scientific challenges of our time. It requires technologically advanced instruments, rigorous methodologies and, above all, the ability to explore possibilities that we do not yet fully understand. In this interview, Dr Andrea Melis, a radio astronomer and First Technologist involved in the search for possible signals from extraterrestrial civilisations, takes us into the world of SETI observations carried out using the Sardinia Radio Telescope, Italy’s largest radio telescope, with its 64-metre dish rising above the Sardinian landscape. From the techniques used to identify possible artificial signals to the collaboration with the Breakthrough Listen project, from the role of artificial intelligence to the limitations of current search strategies, the interview explores the challenges and prospects of a scientific endeavour seeking to answer one of humanity’s fundamental questions: are we alone in the Universe? And in the background, one intriguing question remains: what do we really know about that mysterious, anomalous signal whose nature has yet to be explained?
1. Dr Melis, what kinds of signals are you specifically searching for with the Sardinia Radio Telescope, and how do you distinguish a possible artificial signal coming from space from interference generated by our own terrestrial technologies?
Unlike many SETI searches carried out in commensal mode, that is, by analysing data originally collected for astrophysical observations, at the Sardinia Radio Telescope (as well as at the Medicina radio telescope) we have 150 hours of observing time per year available for targeted searches. We point towards those regions of the sky where we believe the conditions for life are most likely to exist, including life forms belonging to technologically advanced civilisations such as our own. Our searches focus mainly on stars known to host planetary systems, giving priority to those with planets located in the so-called habitable zone, where conditions compatible with the presence of liquid water might exist. In this field, we collaborate with the Breakthrough Listen project and also use catalogues of exoplanets identified by NASA’s TESS mission to select the most promising targets. We mainly search for very narrowband radio signals because natural astrophysical sources generally produce emissions spread across much wider frequency ranges, whereas an artificial transmission can concentrate a significant amount of energy within an extremely narrow band. The main problem is that we also continuously produce signals of this kind on Earth. These are the number one enemy of SETI: the so-called RFI (Radio Frequency Interference). One of the most important tools for distinguishing signals of interest from interference is the analysis of the Doppler effect. As we know, the Earth rotates on its axis and orbits the Sun. A technologically advanced civilisation on another planet would probably experience similar motions, with speeds and periods determined by the characteristics of its own planetary system. As a result, a narrowband radio signal transmitted from a planet many light-years away could reach our radio telescopes showing a gradual change in frequency, known as Doppler drift, caused by the relative motion between transmitter and receiver. Of course, some terrestrial or satellite-based interference can also show frequency drift. For this reason, the Doppler effect alone is not sufficient to establish the extraterrestrial origin of a signal. However, by analysing it together with other characteristics and using modern Machine Learning algorithms, we can identify the most interesting candidates and eliminate a significant proportion of the interference contaminating our observations.
2. SETI searches mainly focus on certain types of radio signals. Is it possible that an extraterrestrial civilisation might use completely different forms of communication from those we are currently able to detect? How can we avoid searching only for what we expect to find?
SETI is perhaps one of humanity’s most ambitious challenges, precisely because we have no evidence that allows us to state with certainty that someone is really out there. We often rely on statistical reasoning, finding it difficult to imagine that a Universe so immense could host life on just one planet, namely Earth, which is itself located in the outer region of one of the hundreds of billions of galaxies that exist. But this remains an argument based on inevitably limited knowledge, because we have only one confirmed example of life: our own. So the answer is yes: it is certainly possible that an extraterrestrial civilisation might use forms of communication completely different from ours. The only way to broaden the scope of this search is to keep pushing the boundaries of our technological and theoretical development. Even today, in order not to restrict ourselves to our own little corner, the SETI community is exploring different approaches, complementing radio astronomy with the search for optical signals, such as laser pulses, and also considering more speculative possibilities, such as neutrino-based communications. In this respect, artificial intelligence already plays, and will continue to play, an increasingly important role, just as it is doing in other areas of scientific research. Some Machine Learning systems, in fact, do not simply search for signals with predefined characteristics. They can analyse enormous quantities of data in search of anomalies, that is, unexpected patterns or behaviours that might escape human observation or traditional algorithms. We must be open-minded and rule nothing out: if an alien civilisation were to use communication techniques based on physical principles that are currently beyond our understanding, our present knowledge and technology might simply be unable to detect them.
3. Despite decades of research, we have not yet confirmed any signal originating from an extraterrestrial civilisation. Can this silence already tell us something about the prevalence of intelligent life in the Universe, or have we explored far too small a portion of the possibilities?
It is true that SETI searches have been going on for decades, but we have explored only an extremely small fraction of the possibilities. In the past, many programmes, such as the famous SETI@home, used data collected during other astronomical observations, while other projects carried out targeted searches of selected stars. Over the last decade, the Breakthrough Listen project has given these activities a major boost, significantly increasing the number of targets observed, the range of frequencies explored and the sensitivity of the searches. Radio telescopes such as Green Bank, Parkes and, of course, our Sardinia Radio Telescope are used to observe thousands of stars, also giving priority to potentially habitable planetary systems. This may seem like a significant number, but compared with the hundreds of billions of planets in our galaxy alone, it is literally like a grain of sand in the Sahara Desert. Furthermore, searches are inevitably limited in terms of the electromagnetic spectrum as well. With the SRT, for example, we have focused on the 4–8 GHz and 18–26 GHz frequency bands. Therefore, failing to detect a signal during an observation does not mean that there is no technological civilisation on that planet, let alone that no form of life exists there. We must also take into account a fundamental factor: time. Radio signals travel at the speed of light, so observing a planet 500 light-years away means receiving information that left that system 500 years ago. The Earth is about 4.6 billion years old, but humanity began producing technological radio transmissions only a little over a century ago: the blink of an eye compared with the entire history of our planet. If an extraterrestrial civilisation had observed Earth at a time before our radio transmissions began, it would not have been able to detect any signals produced by our technologies. If it had concluded from this that there was no intelligent life on our planet, it would have reached a completely wrong conclusion. The silence we observe, therefore, does not prove at all that we are alone. Negative results nevertheless have scientific value, because they allow us to set limits on the presence of certain types of transmitters within the regions and frequency ranges that have been observed. But we are still a very long way from having explored a significant portion of the possibilities.
4. What characteristics make the Sardinian radio telescope particularly useful for SETI, and if an anomalous signal were detected, what checks would be necessary before it could be considered a possible indication of extraterrestrial intelligence?
The Sardinia Radio Telescope (SRT) is one of the most sensitive single-dish radio telescopes in the world. One of its most important characteristics for SETI is the extremely broad frequency coverage for which it was designed, from 0.3 to 116 GHz, which can be progressively explored through its receiver systems. Most radio telescopes involved in SETI operate over more limited frequency ranges. One of the few instruments with comparable characteristics is the Green Bank Telescope (GBT), with which the SRT collaborates to explore higher frequencies, which are still relatively poorly investigated. If an anomalous signal were detected, the first step would be to rule out terrestrial, satellite-based or instrumental interference (RFI). As also described in our scientific papers (Manunza et al.), the main checks include the ON-OFF technique, which makes it possible to determine whether the signal appears only when the radio telescope is pointing towards the source; analysis of Doppler drift, to study changes in frequency over time; and, above all, independent confirmation through observations carried out with another radio telescope. During SETI observations with the SRT, we have detected numerous anomalous signals, almost all of which could be traced back to human-generated interference. There is, however, one signal that continues to give us a hard time: it has characteristics similar to those of electronic interference, but despite the checks carried out, we have not yet been able to establish its nature with certainty. This does not mean that it is extraterrestrial in origin, nor that there is sufficient evidence to consider it a signal produced by an alien civilisation. It does, however, demonstrate how difficult it is to distinguish a genuinely interesting signal from interference, and how important scientific rigour and caution are when interpreting results.
5. How would humanity change if we found evidence of extraterrestrial intelligence? From a scientific point of view, what would be the first step after a credible detection? And, given the enormous distances in the Universe and the time required for communication, should we expect to be able to engage in dialogue with another civilisation, or might the discovery be limited to confirming that we are not alone?
Faced with certain proof that we are not alone in the Universe, I believe humanity should embark on a process of profound reflection on the meaning of its own existence. It would be a genuine existential earthquake, comparable, in some respects, to the profound change in one’s perception of life that can be experienced by someone who has faced and overcome a serious illness. From that moment on, everything might take on a different meaning, with the hope that humanity would stop waging wars and join forces to reach that inhabited planet one day, perhaps. From a scientific point of view, however, the first step after a credible detection would be independent verification of the signal. In accordance with recently updated international SETI protocols, other observatories would need to be involved in an attempt to confirm the result, rule out terrestrial interference or natural phenomena, and share the evidence with the scientific community before speaking of a confirmed discovery. In this context, a project currently under development called A Sign in Space 2 is particularly relevant. It is being carried out in collaboration with ESA and, in particular, with the team behind the JUICE mission. The aim is to recreate a realistic scenario involving the reception of a hypothetical extraterrestrial signal and to test coordination protocols among SETI observing stations, assessing their effectiveness in a real-world situation. It will be a very important experiment, allowing us researchers to test the effectiveness of coordination protocols in practice and to prepare more thoroughly for a possible real discovery. Finally, given the enormous distances involved, we should not necessarily expect to be able to establish a genuine dialogue with another civilisation. Since signals travel at the speed of light, communication with a system hundreds or thousands of light-years away would require timescales incompatible with a human lifetime. We could therefore find ourselves in a situation where we receive a signal but might never obtain a reply to a message we send in response. And yet, even without the possibility of dialogue, we would still have made one of the most extraordinary discoveries in human history: confirmation that we are not alone in the Universe.
By Claudio Luigi Bagni
