SETI: how much weight does the average duration of a technological civilization in estimates when calculating the probability of contact?
You’re asking about how much the average duration of a technological civilization influences the probability of contact with extraterrestrial civilizations—essentially a question rooted in the Drake Equation framework. Let’s break it down carefully.
1. The Role of Civilization Lifetime in Contact Probability
In the Drake Equation, one of the factors is:L=average lifetime of a technological civilization (years)
The probability of contact is directly proportional to L. Why? Because even if intelligent civilizations appear frequently, they must exist at the same time as us to make contact possible. A civilization that lasts only 100 years is much less likely to overlap with us than one that lasts a million years.
Mathematically:N=R∗⋅fp⋅ne⋅fl⋅fi⋅fc⋅L
Where N is the number of civilizations we could potentially contact right now. The L term is literally the “weight” of temporal overlap: the longer civilizations last, the higher the probability that some exist at the same time as us.
2. Quantitative Effect
Suppose you have two civilizations:
- Civilization A lasts 100 years
- Civilization B lasts 1,000,000 years
If the rate of emergence of civilizations is constant, the probability that you are contemporaneous with A is 10,000 times smaller than with B. That’s huge.
So the weight of L in calculating the probability of contact is massive—it’s effectively a scaling factor.
3. Why Estimates of L Are So Uncertain
- Human technological civilization is ~100 years old, and we don’t know if we’ll last 500 or 10,000 years.
- Many models of the Fermi Paradox hinge on L being short; even if life is common, if L is small, contact is extremely unlikely.
Some studies suggest that LLL dominates uncertainty in the Drake Equation more than the number of habitable planets or fraction developing life.
✅ Key Takeaways
- Direct Proportionality: Longer-lasting civilizations = higher chance of contact.
- Dominant Factor: Among the Drake Equation parameters, L often carries the most weight in determining N.
- Temporal Overlap: Civilizations must exist simultaneously—so even abundant civilizations with short lifespans may be undetectable.
In collaboration with ChatGPT